MLB Game Prediction

San Francisco Giants vs St. Louis Cardinals Prediction & Betting Tips for 9/23/2025

Want our best San Francisco Giants vs St. Louis Cardinals prediction for 9/23/25? Get our MLB betting tip as the Cardinals travel to the Giants on 9/23/25 at Oracle Park, in San Francisco. Knup Sports has your free pick!

The St. Louis Cardinals, with a record of 76-80, are set to play the San Francisco Giants, who hold a 77-79 record, at Oracle Park. Both teams are positioned fourth in their respective divisions, with the Cardinals trailing by 19 games in the NL Central and the Giants 11 games behind in the NL West. This night game on Tuesday, September 23, 2025, will be broadcasted on FDSMW under clear skies with a light breeze.

Led by manager Oliver Marmol, the Cardinals come into this game with a recent win against the Milwaukee Brewers, where they showcased a resilient performance by limiting their opponent to just one run. However, the team has had a mixed bag of results in their last 10 games, holding a 4-6 record. With a road record of 32-43, they will need to find a spark to gain momentum at Oracle Park.

The Giants, managed by Bob Melvin, are also on the back of a victory, having secured a 3-1 win against the Los Angeles Dodgers. Despite a recent slump with a 3-7 record in their last 10 games, they have shown resilience at home with a 38-37 record. The game odds favor the Giants, with a moneyline of -197, but with both teams needing a win, it promises to be an intriguing contest.

Giants vs Cardinals At a Glance

  • Game Location: Oracle Park in San Francisco, CA
  • Game Time: Tuesday, September 23, 2025, at 9:45 PM
  • Cardinals Record: 76-80, 4th in NL Central
  • Giants Record: 77-79, 4th in NL West
  • Weather: Clear sky with a light breeze
  • TV Broadcast: FDSMW

The Giants’ Next Test: St. Louis Cardinals Showdown

Cardinals’ Offensive Overview

The St. Louis Cardinals enter this matchup with a batting average that positions them in the middle of the league, suggesting a solid but not exceptional offensive lineup. Their on-base percentage ranks slightly better, indicating their ability to capitalize on getting players on base.

However, the Cardinals’ slugging percentage is a concern as it ranks 23rd, which could limit their scoring potential against a team like the Giants with a competitive pitching staff.

Key Players to Watch

Andre Pallante will be on the mound for the Cardinals, bringing an ERA of 5.29 and a WHIP of 1.44. His record this season stands at 6-15, highlighting struggles in securing wins despite having decent control over his pitches.

On the offensive side, the Cardinals will look to their key hitters to generate runs, particularly given their ranking of 16th in home runs. Consistency in offensive production will be crucial against the Giants’ pitching.

Cardinals’ Recent Performances

In recent games, the Cardinals have experienced a mixed bag of results, reflecting their mid-tier standing in various statistical categories. The team’s ability to perform under pressure and deliver key hits in crucial moments remains to be a pivotal factor in their outcomes.

As the Cardinals gear up to play the Giants, they will need to address their rank of 25th in doubles, as extra-base hits could be a game-changer in this matchup.

Betting Trends for the Cardinals

  • Recent form suggests inconsistency, which can be seen in their fluctuating win-loss records over the past few games.
  • The Cardinals have struggled to secure victories when listed as underdogs, which might be the case against the Giants.
  • Despite challenges, their performance in close games indicates potential to compete effectively in tight contests.

Can the Cardinals Slow Down the Giants’ Momentum?

Giants’ Offensive Overview

The San Francisco Giants enter the game with a batting average ranked 14th in the league at .245, showcasing a decent offensive capability. Their on-base percentage sits at .313, placing them 15th, indicating they find ways to get on base consistently.

Despite ranking 24th in home runs with 143, the Giants have managed to hit a significant number of doubles, ranking 13th with 248. This ability to hit doubles could prove advantageous against the Cardinals’ pitching staff.

Power and Plate Discipline

The Giants’ lineup is disciplined at the plate, as indicated by their rank of 23rd in walks with 462 this season. However, their slugging percentage of .378 is ranked 24th, suggesting that they might struggle to hit for power consistently.

With 1257 strikeouts, ranked 9th, the Giants’ hitters face a challenge of making consistent contact. This could play into the hands of Cardinals’ starter Andre Pallante if he can exploit this weakness.

Giants’ Pitching Strengths

On the mound, the Giants are led by Logan Webb, who boasts a solid ERA of 3.27 and a WHIP of 1.24. Webb has recorded a respectable 14-11 win-loss record, indicating his ability to keep his team in games.

As a team, the Giants have a collective ERA of 4.24, ranked 20th, and a batting average against of .258, ranked 17th. These stats suggest they have been relatively effective at limiting opponents’ offensive production.

Challenges in the Bullpen

One area of concern for the Giants is their 6th-ranked blown saves with 23, indicating potential vulnerabilities in closing out games. This might offer the Cardinals an opportunity to capitalize on late-game situations.

Despite these challenges, the Giants’ pitching staff has been effective in limiting home runs, allowing only 157, which is the 4th best in the league. This could be a key factor against a Cardinals lineup that has shown power potential.

Betting Trends for the Giants

  • SU Last 3 Games: 2-1 (66.7%)
  • SU as Favorite: 33-33 (50.0%)
  • SU in Home Games: 44-37 (54.3%)
  • Runline as Underdog: 54-36 (60.0%)
  • O/U All Games: 77-79 (49.4%)
  • O/U Totals ≤ 7.5: 23-16 (59.0%)

Giants vs Cardinals Prediction: Cardinals +166

The St. Louis Cardinals are coming into the game with a moneyline of +166, making them the underdogs. Despite their current streak and road record, they have managed to perform better against the Giants historically, showing consistency in head-to-head matchups with a slight edge. With Andre Pallante starting, they look to leverage his experience despite his higher ERA.

In contrast, the Giants will have Logan Webb on the mound, whose performance this season has been solid with a 3.27 ERA. However, the Giants have struggled against the Cardinals in recent meetings, and their recent form has been less than stellar with a 3-7 record in their last 10 games. The Cardinals, with a more consistent overall showing in recent games, can capitalize on their momentum.

Given the Cardinals’ underdog status and past success against the Giants, betting on them presents a potentially rewarding opportunity. Additionally, the Cardinals have managed to overcome the Giants in two out of the last three encounters, suggesting they have the formula to succeed in this matchup.

Considering the factors above, expect a close game with the Cardinals edging out a narrow win. The projected final score could see the Cardinals take it 4-3 over the Giants, using their historical edge and recent momentum.

  • Giants vs Cardinals Prediction: Cardinals +166
  • Giants vs Cardinals Score: Cardinals 4 – Giants 3
To Top