NHL Game Prediction

Pittsburgh Penguins vs New York Islanders Prediction & Betting Tips for 10/9/2025

Want our best Pittsburgh Penguins vs New York Islanders prediction for on 10/9/25? Get our NHL betting tip as the Islanders travel to the Penguins on 10/9/25 at PPG Paints Arena, in Pittsburgh. Knup Sports has your free pick!

The NHL regular season is set to begin with the New York Islanders traveling to face the Pittsburgh Penguins at PPG Paints Arena. The game is scheduled for Thursday, October 9, 2025, at 7:00 PM and will be broadcast on ESPN+. This marks an intriguing start as both teams aim to establish momentum early in the season.

Leading the Islanders is head coach Patrick Roy, who will be looking to improve upon last season’s 35-35-12 record. Despite finishing 12th in the conference and missing the playoffs, the Islanders come into this game as the favorites with a moneyline of -128. Their division record last season stood at 11-15, which they will aim to better under Roy’s guidance.

The Penguins, coached by Dan Muse, have kicked off their season with a 1-0 record, including a shutout win. With the home advantage, Pittsburgh enters as the underdog with a moneyline of +108. The game presents a chance for the Penguins to capitalize on their early win and challenge a divisional opponent.

Penguins vs Islanders At a Glance

  • Venue: PPG Paints Arena
  • Game Date & Time: Thursday, October 9, 2025 at 7:00 PM
  • TV Channel: ESPN+
  • New York Islanders Last Season Record: 35-35-12
  • Pittsburgh Penguins Current Season Record: 1-0
  • Odds Favorite: New York Islanders (-128)

The Penguins Prepare to Face the Islanders in Upcoming Game

Team Overview

The Pittsburgh Penguins are coming off an impressive 3-0 victory against the New York Rangers. This strong performance in their season opener sets a positive tone for their upcoming games. The Penguins have a series of challenging matchups ahead, starting with the New York Islanders.

Despite a solid start, the Penguins face injury challenges, including key players like Joel Blomqvist and Bryan Rust on the injured reserve list. Coach Dan Muse’s decision to integrate rookies into the lineup suggests a strategy focused on building depth and resilience.

Key Players to Watch

One of the rookies making headlines is Ben Kindel, who played over 15 minutes in his NHL debut. His strong performance included one shot on goal and winning four of five faceoffs, indicating his potential impact on the team.

Harrison Brunicke also made his debut, showing improvement throughout the game despite early challenges. His ability to adapt and contribute, even in high-pressure situations, bodes well for the Penguins’ future.

Goaltending and Defense

Arturs Silovs played a pivotal role in the Penguins’ win by recording a shutout against the Rangers. His performance was a testament to his skill and potential as a key goaltender for the team this season.

On defense, Parker Wotherspoon logged significant ice time in the opener, playing alongside Erik Karlsson. Their developing chemistry is expected to bolster the Penguins’ defensive stability in upcoming games.

Betting Trends

  • SU Last 3: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • SU Last 5: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • SU Last 10: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • SU All Games: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • SU as Underdog: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • Puckline Last 3: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • Puckline Last 5: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • Puckline Last 10: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • Puckline All Games: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • Puckline as Underdog: 1-0 (100.0%)
  • O/U Last 3: 0-1 (0.0%)
  • O/U Last 5: 0-1 (0.0%)
  • O/U Last 10: 0-1 (0.0%)
  • O/U All Games: 0-1 (0.0%)

The Penguins’ betting trends reflect their perfect record thus far, with a strong performance in their first game. As the season progresses, these trends will be crucial for bettors and fans alike to monitor.

New York Islanders: Ready to Start the Season on the Road

Key Skaters to Watch

The Islanders’ offensive hopes rest heavily on Bo Horvat, who led the team last season with 57 points in 81 games. His contribution will be pivotal as they face the Penguins, especially given his role on the top line.

Anders Lee brings strength and consistency, having netted 29 goals last season. His physical presence, evident from 121 hits, will be crucial in maintaining offensive pressure.

Up-and-Coming Talent

Jonathan Drouin is expected to add dynamism to the Islanders’ attack. After scoring 37 points in 43 games with the Avalanche, his potential impact is significant, especially on the top line alongside Horvat.

Rookie Matthew Schaefer will make his NHL debut. He has shown promise in the preseason with over 22 minutes of ice time per game and solid possession metrics.

Goaltending Situation

Ilya Sorokin remains the Islanders’ top choice between the pipes after recording 30 wins last season. His ability to keep the goals against low will be a focal point against Pittsburgh.

With Semyon Varlamov on injured reserve, the pressure on Sorokin increases, especially as David Rittich steps into a backup role with 16 wins last season.

Injury Concerns

The Islanders face early challenges with Calum Ritchie out due to a lower-body injury. His absence could affect the team’s depth early in the season.

Other players on the injured list include Ethan Bear and Pierre Engvall, impacting both the defense and forward lines.

Islanders’ Betting Trends

  • SU Last 3: 1-2 (33.3%)
  • SU Last 5: 2-3 (40.0%)
  • SU Last 10: 3-7 (30.0%)
  • SU All Games: 28-35 (44.4%)
  • SU as Favorite: 13-15 (46.4%)
  • SU as Underdog: 15-20 (42.9%)
  • Puckline Last 3: 0-3 (0.0%)
  • Puckline Last 5: 1-4 (20.0%)
  • Puckline Last 10: 2-8 (20.0%)
  • Puckline All Games: 27-36 (42.9%)
  • Puckline as Favorite: 13-15 (46.4%)
  • Puckline as Underdog: 14-21 (40.0%)
  • O/U Last 3: 1-2 (33.3%)
  • O/U Last 5: 2-3 (40.0%)
  • O/U Last 10: 5-5 (50.0%)
  • O/U All Games: 27-36 (42.9%)

Penguins vs Islanders Prediction: Penguins +108

The Pittsburgh Penguins have started the season strongly with a 3-0 shutout against the New York Rangers, showcasing a stellar performance from their newly appointed starting goalie, Arturs Silovs. Given the team’s positive start and the energy from their home crowd at PPG Paints Arena, they appear well-positioned to continue their winning momentum. With a +108 moneyline, the Penguins offer good value as a slight underdog against the Islanders.

Conversely, the New York Islanders are entering the season with uncertainties, particularly concerning their lineup and injuries. Key player Calum Ritchie is dealing with a lower-body injury, which could impact their offensive depth. The Islanders’ recent roster changes and potential lineup issues give the Penguins an edge in this matchup.

Pittsburgh’s mix of seasoned veterans like Sidney Crosby and emerging talents, such as Ben Kindel, provides a balanced lineup capable of challenging any team. Their recent win highlighted their defensive strength, particularly in shutting down a strong opponent like the Rangers. With such a promising start, the Penguins are likely to capitalize on the Islanders’ weaknesses and secure a victory.

Given these factors, the Penguins’ depth, home advantage, and recent form suggest a win in their upcoming game against the Islanders. I project a final score of Penguins 4 – Islanders 2, aligning with their current form and the Islanders’ potential vulnerabilities.

  • Penguins vs Islanders Prediction: Penguins +108
  • Penguins vs Islanders Score: Penguins 4 – Islanders 2
To Top