MLB Game Prediction

Boston Red Sox vs Athletics Prediction & Betting Tips for 9/17/2025

Want our best Boston Red Sox vs Athletics prediction for 9/17/25? Get our MLB betting tip as the Athletics travel to the Red Sox on 9/17/25 at Fenway Park, in Boston. Knup Sports has your free pick!

The Athletics, currently on a five-game winning streak, will travel to Fenway Park to take on the Boston Red Sox on September 17, 2025. Sitting at a record of 71-80 and ranked fourth in the AL West division, the Athletics have shown recent improvement, winning seven of their last ten games. Their road record stands at 38-38, which they aim to bolster against a challenging Red Sox lineup.

The Boston Red Sox enter this game with an 82-69 record and are ranked third in the AL East division. Despite their strong home record of 45-31, the Red Sox have encountered some difficulties lately, losing six of their last ten games, including a narrow 2-1 defeat to the Athletics in their previous encounter. Manager Alex Cora will look to turn things around at home with the support of the Fenway faithful.

The consensus odds position the Red Sox as the favorites with a moneyline of -186, while the Athletics stand at +156. Both teams will look to capitalize on the mild weather conditions with overcast clouds and a light breeze expected. The game is set to be broadcast on NSPCA, promising a notable contest between two teams with contrasting recent form.

Red Sox vs Athletics At a Glance

  • Game Location: Fenway Park in Boston, MA
  • Weather Conditions: Mild day with a light breeze, overcast clouds expected
  • Current Streaks: Athletics are on a 5-game winning streak, Red Sox have lost their last game
  • TV Coverage: Watch live on NSPCA
  • Odds Snapshot: Athletics moneyline +156, Red Sox moneyline -186
  • Game Time: September 17, 2025, at 6:45 PM

Boston Red Sox Look to Bounce Back Against the Athletics

Overview of the Athletics’ Hitting

The Athletics enter this game with a solid batting average of .254, ranking 4th in the league. Their on-base percentage stands at .323, placing them 6th, showing they have the ability to get on base and create scoring opportunities. However, their power numbers are slightly lower, with 177 home runs, ranking 14th.

Leading the league with 303 doubles, the Athletics demonstrate a knack for hitting the ball into gaps, which can be key in driving in runs. Their discipline at the plate is also evident with 483 walks, ranked 12th. On the base paths, they have been successful with 128 stolen bases, placing them 6th in the league.

Athletics’ Pitching Staff Performance

The Athletics’ pitching staff holds a commendable ERA of 3.73, ranked 4th, indicating their ability to keep opponents’ scoring in check. They have allowed a batting average against of .244, placing them 11th, which signifies some vulnerability to hits. A strength of their pitching staff is limiting home runs, as they’ve only given up 155, ranked 4th.

With 68 quality starts, the Athletics’ rotation has been reliable, contributing to their ability to remain competitive in games. However, blown saves have been an issue, with 27, ranking 10th. Their bullpen’s performance in high-pressure situations might be an area of concern for the team.

Key Players to Watch

Mason Barnett takes the mound for the Athletics, sporting an ERA of 8.53 and a WHIP of 1.90, along with a 1-1 record. Barnett will need to improve his control and effectiveness to give the Athletics a chance against the Red Sox. His ability to handle the Red Sox lineup will be crucial in determining the outcome of the game.

Offensively, the Athletics will rely on their ability to hit doubles and take advantage of scoring opportunities. Their lineup’s discipline at the plate will be tested against Lucas Giolito, who has an ERA of 3.31 and a WHIP of 1.25. The Athletics’ ability to put pressure on Giolito could dictate the flow of the game.

Betting Trends for the Athletics

  • SU Last 3 Games: 2-1 (66.7%)
  • SU Last 5 Games: 3-2 (60.0%)
  • SU Last 10 Games: 5-5 (50.0%)
  • SU in Away Games: 20-30 (40.0%)
  • Runline Last 3: 2-1 (66.7%)
  • Runline Last 5: 3-2 (60.0%)
  • Runline Last 10: 5-5 (50.0%)
  • O/U Last 3: 1-2 (33.3%)
  • O/U Last 5: 2-3 (40.0%)

Athletics Aim for Continued Success Against the Red Sox

Team Overview

The Athletics are set to play the Boston Red Sox at Fenway Park, entering the game with a five-game winning streak. Their performance has been bolstered by strong offensive stats, including a .255 batting average, ranking third in the league.

On the mound, Mason Barnett will start for the Athletics, carrying an ERA of 8.53. Despite his struggles, the team remains confident due to their recent success and strong bullpen performance.

Key Offensive Players

Nick Kurtz stands out as a key player with a batting average of .296 and 32 home runs. His contributions are vital, as he leads the team in both home runs and RBIs with 80.

Shea Langeliers is another crucial player, hitting .263 with 30 home runs. His power and consistency make him a formidable presence in the lineup.

Jacob Wilson has been an important asset with a batting average of .317. His ability to get on base frequently adds depth to the Athletics’ offensive capabilities.

Pitching Challenges

The Athletics’ pitching staff has had its ups and downs, with a team ERA of 4.75, placing them 26th in the league. Despite this, their bullpen has shown improvement, highlighted by their recent performance against the Red Sox.

Mason Barnett will need to find his rhythm quickly to limit the potent Red Sox lineup. The Athletics will rely on their bullpen to maintain the lead if Barnett faces difficulties early on.

Recent Game Performances

The Athletics have won their last five games, showing a strong overall team performance. Their offense has been particularly effective, scoring multiple home runs in recent games against the Cincinnati Reds.

In their recent game against the Red Sox, the Athletics managed a narrow 2-1 win, thanks to timely hitting and a strong bullpen effort. This win was part of their ongoing successful run.

Betting Trends

  • SU Last 3 Games: 3-0 (100.0%)
  • SU in Away Games: 38-38 (50.0%)
  • Runline as Underdog: 68-46 (59.6%)
  • O/U All Games: 74-77 (49.0%)

Red Sox vs Athletics Prediction: Athletics +156

The Athletics have been on a hot streak, winning their last five games, which includes a victory over the Red Sox. Their recent form makes them an enticing pick at +156, especially considering the Red Sox’s current struggles offensively. Despite Boston’s better overall record, their inconsistency makes the Athletics a viable underdog option.

Mason Barnett takes the mound for Oakland, bringing a high ERA of 8.53, which is a concern. However, the Red Sox’s inability to capitalize with runners in scoring position, as evidenced by their last game, suggests Barnett might have a better outing than expected. Boston’s Lucas Giolito, with his 3.31 ERA, will present a challenge, but the Athletics’ recent performances against strong pitchers give them a fighting chance.

The Athletics’ bullpen has been instrumental in their recent success, delivering strong performances in the second half of the season. Their ability to hold leads could be pivotal again in this matchup. Given the recent head-to-head results, with the Athletics taking a close game against the Red Sox, another tight contest seems likely.

Considering the Athletics’ momentum and the potential for Barnett to receive solid run support, a close game is expected. Projecting a score of Athletics 4 – Red Sox 3 aligns with the Athletics’ ability to capitalize on Boston’s current woes and their own recent strong performances.

  • Red Sox vs Athletics Prediction: Athletics +156
  • Red Sox vs Athletics Score: Athletics 4 – Red Sox 3
To Top