MLB Game Prediction

New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays Prediction & Betting Tips for 9/5/2025

Want our best New York Yankees vs Toronto Blue Jays prediction for 9/5/25? Get our MLB betting tip as the Blue Jays travel to the Yankees on 9/5/25 at Yankee Stadium, in New York. Knup Sports has your free pick!

The Toronto Blue Jays, with a record of 81-59, are set to visit the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium. The Blue Jays lead the AL East division, showing resilience with a recent two-game winning streak and a balanced last ten games at 5-5. Under the guidance of manager John Schneider, they look to extend their lead in the division.

The New York Yankees, trailing closely with a record of 78-62, are second in the AL East, just three games behind the Blue Jays. They have been in excellent form lately, winning eight of their last ten games, and manager Aaron Boone will be looking to capitalize on their current momentum. Playing at home, where they have a 41-28 record, the Yankees are poised for a competitive series.

The game will take place on Friday, September 5, 2025, at 7:05 PM, with clear skies and a light breeze expected. Broadcast on MLBN, fans can expect an exciting showdown between these two division rivals. The betting consensus has the Yankees as the favorites with a moneyline of -132, while the Blue Jays are set at +113.

Yankees vs Blue Jays At a Glance

  • Game Location: Yankee Stadium in New York, NY
  • Weather Conditions: Clear skies with a warm day and light breeze crosswind
  • Broadcasting Info: Watch the game on MLBN
  • Team Records: Blue Jays are 81-59, Yankees are 78-62
  • Current Division Standings: Blue Jays rank 1st, Yankees rank 2nd in the AL East
  • Betting Odds: Yankees favored with a moneyline of -132

Yankees Gear Up for Showdown Against Toronto Blue Jays

Blue Jays Offensive Analysis

The Toronto Blue Jays have displayed a strong offensive presence this season, leveraging power and agility to challenge opposing pitchers. They have a respectable batting average, indicating consistent contact with the ball. Their ability to drive in runs has been a key component of their strategy.

The team’s lineup is peppered with capable hitters who can change the game with one swing. They thrive on creating scoring opportunities and have shown a knack for capitalizing on them. Their performance will be crucial in the upcoming game against the Yankees.

Key Players to Watch

Kevin Gausman is set to take the mound for the Blue Jays, bringing a solid ERA of 3.75 into the game. With a WHIP of 1.05, Gausman has shown efficiency in keeping runners off base. His performance will be pivotal in setting the tone against the Yankees’ powerful lineup.

The Blue Jays’ lineup features a mix of power hitters and contact specialists. Players who can get on base and apply pressure will be instrumental in testing the Yankees’ defensive strategies. The ability to execute timely hits will be a focal point for Toronto.

Pitching Strategy and Defense

Toronto’s pitching staff has been effective in controlling the game’s tempo. Their ability to limit home runs and maintain a steady strikeout rate has been beneficial throughout the season. This consistency will be essential in facing a formidable Yankees offense.

Defensively, the Blue Jays are equipped to handle pressure situations, having demonstrated resilience in close games. Their fielding will need to be sharp to thwart any offensive bursts from the Yankees. This aspect of their game could be a deciding factor in the matchup.

Team Betting Trends

  • SU Last 3 Games: 2-1 (66.7%)
  • SU Last 5 Games: 3-2 (60.0%)
  • SU Last 10 Games: 8-2 (80.0%)
  • SU All Games: 78-62 (55.7%)
  • SU as Favorite: 70-50 (58.3%)
  • SU as Underdog: 8-12 (40.0%)
  • Runline Last 3: 2-1 (66.7%)
  • Runline Last 5: 3-2 (60.0%)
  • Runline Last 10: 8-2 (80.0%)
  • O/U Last 3: 2-1 (66.7%)
  • O/U Last 5: 2-3 (40.0%)
  • O/U Last 10: 6-4 (60.0%)

Blue Jays Look to Continue Their Dominance Against the Yankees

Yankees’ Team Overview

The New York Yankees are preparing to take on the Toronto Blue Jays with a record of 2-2 under the pitching of Cam Schlittler. With a 2.61 ERA and a WHIP of 1.24, Schlittler will be looking to help his team secure a victory.

Despite recent struggles, the Yankees have been competitive, showing resilience in their performances. Their upcoming series against the Blue Jays is crucial as they aim to improve their standings.

Cam Schlittler’s Impact

Cam Schlittler’s performance on the mound has been impressive, maintaining a 2.61 ERA. His ability to keep hitters off balance has been key to his success so far this season.

With a WHIP of 1.24, Schlittler’s control has been a significant factor in his outings, allowing him to limit baserunners and minimize damage. The Yankees will rely on his pitching prowess to challenge the Blue Jays’ lineup.

Key Yankees Players to Watch

As the Yankees prepare for the series, attention will be on their lineup to produce runs against a formidable Blue Jays pitching staff. Consistent contributions from the offense will be essential for New York to compete.

The Yankees’ defense will also play a crucial role in supporting Schlittler’s efforts on the mound. Timely fielding and preventing extra-base hits will be vital to their success in this series.

Yankees’ Recent Trends

  • The Yankees are currently 2-2 when Cam Schlittler starts.
  • New York has been able to stay competitive in close games.
  • Offensive production has been inconsistent, highlighting the need for improvement.

Yankees’ Betting Trends

  • Yankees are 2-2 in games started by Cam Schlittler.
  • New York tends to struggle in games with high-pressure situations.
  • The Yankees’ runline performance has been varied, depending on pitching matchups.
  • They have fared better in games where they score early and maintain momentum.
  • The Yankees have had mixed results in away games, impacting their overall record.

Yankees vs Blue Jays Prediction: Over 8.5

The upcoming game between the Toronto Blue Jays and New York Yankees features two teams with potent offenses. The Blue Jays, led by George Springer and Daulton Varsho, have shown a consistent ability to score, averaging over six runs per game in their recent outings. With Yankee Stadium as the venue, known for being favorable to hitters, the conditions are ripe for a high-scoring contest.

Kevin Gausman and Cam Schlittler, the starting pitchers, have had solid seasons, but both teams’ recent performances suggest their offenses could overpower pitching efforts. The Yankees’ recent performance, averaging 5+ runs in games where they have hit the over, supports the expectation of a lively offensive battle. Given these factors, the over 8.5 seems a reasonable pick.

The head-to-head history between these teams further supports a high-scoring game. In their last 10 meetings, the over has hit six times, demonstrating the offensive firepower both teams can bring. With the weather forecast indicating clear skies and favorable conditions for hitters, we can anticipate both teams capitalizing on these opportunities.

Considering all these aspects, a projected final score for the game could be Blue Jays 6 – Yankees 5, totaling 11 runs. This aligns with the expectation for a competitive, high-scoring game, making the over 8.5 a compelling choice for bettors.

  • Yankees vs Blue Jays Prediction: Over 8.5
  • Yankees vs Blue Jays Score: Blue Jays 6 – Yankees 5
To Top